5

Yes, we should have such threads Sometimes good posts (questions and answers alike) are forgotten and never appear in the review queue after closure or deletion (there needs to be at least one vote for reopening/undeletion for that). And even if it is in the review queue, this queue in particular rarely gets the attention it deserves so that we rarely have ...


2

The question was flagged as 'not an answer'. The standard system-side procedure when moderators approve that kind of flag is deletion. So why did I delete this answer? Firstly because it is, other than you imply, quite opinionated. Good as rational is one view among others and in contemporary philosophy certainly not the most discussed one. You even state ...


1

Your answer appeared in the "Low Quality Posts" review queue. That is where I voted to delete your answer because I did not think it was answering the question. Rather it seemed to have some other motivation in being there. I may have made a mistake, but in looking at the answer again, I continue to find it puzzling. I recommend writing a different ...


1

(This is the same reply moved from the other thread) John Slegers, I'm sorry you are having difficulties with a moderator. I hope we can get over that little hiccup soon, as we really do want you to participate here and not scare you away. I do want to comment on your statement though with regards to what philosophy is "all about": Philosophy is all ...


Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible