Is the answer just "no-one"?
I have to agree with the following comment:
"This edit does not look particularly opinion based [sic]...– Conifold Nov 7 at 19:59"
It's been my experience that some who vote to close are the same who frequently find their own questions closed, particularly regarding the question of what constitutes opinion as used as criterion offered by the site. As far as I can tell, there are those whose reputations accurately reflect a serious cogency and demonstration of scholarship, and others who through marginal contributions accrue points scattershot. (And yes, I'm in the latter category!)