0

Does anybody know any good alternatives to this site? I don't like how this channel is being moderated and the fact that your freedom of speech is not guaranteed.

For a number of reasons I would like to find a place in which people are more tolerant towards questions that intellectually challenge you, in which as long as your questions are respectful and interesting they are respected and not closed by ego-maniac people with PhDs and you don't have to follow a Pro USA-capitalism ideology.

UPDATE As said by one of the moderators I would like to find a platform in which Philosophical ideas can be discussed. Does anybody have any recommendations?

  • 1
    You clearly are the respectful and reasonable part of the discussion here, are you? StackExchange is about knowledge, so speculation (capitalist, socialist, or otherwise) is a bad fit even if you are intellectually unchallenged by anything but intuition/speculation. AFAIR, there is a fair amount of (unchallenged) questions and answers neutrally discussing Marxism, anarchy, and other doctrines critical of capitalism as well. So please, watch your tone. – Philip Klöcking Nov 20 '18 at 8:14
  • @PhilipKlöcking speculation and thought experiments are necessary to attain knowledge. This channels proves how wrong western philosophy is and how the ego of the "philosophers" specially the ones with PhDs intercedes with truth and the search for it. “Doubt is the origin of wisdom” ― René Descartes – PbxMan Nov 20 '18 at 8:25
  • 2
    Exactly, they are necessary to attain knowledge. Since StackExchange is about (existing) knowledge (experts answering your questions) and not about obtaining original knowledge, they are misplaced here. The whole point of a Q & A format is to have the answer to the question and not a bunch of open questions soliciting speculative responses. Nobody restricts the subject-matter of questions and answers here, only the mode of questioning and answering. I am well aware that this does not suit the practice of philosophy well, alas this does not change the facts. – Philip Klöcking Nov 20 '18 at 8:33
  • @PhilipKlöcking you have plenty of examples here tagged as "thought-experiments" that have been discussed. Some specific questions asking for authors or references have been closed and downvoted and even deleted. Speculation can lead to logic and logic to truth. Facts or objective truth are something to speculate about with logic an critical thinking skills in ordinary philosophy forums. – PbxMan Nov 20 '18 at 8:41
  • The thought-experiments discussed usually are variants of well-established ones discussed countless times in the literature. Let's face it: The aspiration of speculatively obtaining new and original "facts" or "objective truth" in philosophy is hubris. You may find new ways to express something, but sincere studies of philosophy show you that there always have been others thinking and writing materially the same. Also, Philosophy.SE is StackExchange first and foremost, not a philosophy "forum" for exchanging philosophical ideas. – Philip Klöcking Nov 20 '18 at 8:49
  • @PhilipKlöcking My last question suits all your premises. Let's see how long until it's closed – PbxMan Nov 20 '18 at 12:09
2

You could consider Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/philosophy/

I don't know if it is better than this site, but it seems to be similar and a popular alternative.

You could stay here. Part of participating in discussions is using language to interact with real people. If a question is closed, find another way to approach the subject. Don't worry about it except to learn from the experience and try again.

Anyone may ask or answer questions here. No one has to be an expert to do either. No one has to have a PhD in philosophy. I don't and I write often. That doesn't mean everyone will like the questions or answers that I offer.

  • I disagree with you on the closing question part. To me it's more like censorship and not everybody is trained to be a judge. Some of my questions specially related to 9/11 are not closed but deleted! To some people it's just a nut-case "conspiracy theory" to me it's just a revolution of the mind just like relativity or evolution. Time will tell... Thanks for your advice I have already found another more suitable forum to my needs. – PbxMan Nov 23 '18 at 12:02
  • @PbxMan Best wishes. I hope things work out for you on that forum. The people here who are making judgments can be anyone with adequate reputation and who want to participate. No one need have any training or experience. Those interested in being active here also change over time. So what is accepted or not today may be different from what is accepted or not a year from now. – Frank Hubeny Nov 23 '18 at 14:07

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .