This question already has an answer here:
- Should we explain downvotes? 3 answers
Some people downvote a question or an answer but don't comment on what's wrong with it. This is problematic. Either the downvoter is wrong or the downvoted answer is wrong and there is no way to tell which is true, even in principle, without an argument let alone fix any problems. Would there be a way to require a comment in order to downvote it and would that be desirable?