Something that just occurred to me is that I'm not sure when a vote to close a question should be used as opposed to a downvote. It seems that every case where I would downvote (the question is vague and unclear, argumentative, etc.) is also a case where I would vote to close. In fact, surveying my downvotes and my votes to close, it seems that in almost every instance since I could vote to close that my downvotes were accompanied by a vote to close. But then that just seems a bit redundant.

Since I've only had the vote to close privilege for a short while, I think that maybe I haven't picked up on the subtle differences here. Is there one? Or for users with the privilege to vote to close will the legitimate reasons for a downvote coincide with reasons for a vote to close?

1 Answer 1


Downvotes are for questions that do not show any research effort; are unclear or not useful. Close votes are essentially the same for me except I only close to either put questions in a holding zone while they are being improved to prevent tons of irrelevant answers or when the question is at a point where I think, based on the evidence at hand, that it will not be improved or is beyond salvaging. It is, of course, always best to edit to improve a question where you can, or at least add a comment about how to do so rather than simply voting to close or downvoting, but most people including you seem to recognize that thankfully.

See also:
When to downvote, when to close vote, when to do both?
Downvotes versus close votes on questions

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .